elemental theater
by Douglas Messerli
Philippe Quesne La Mélancolie des dragons / the performance I saw was in Los
Angeles at Redcat (Roy and Edna Disney/Calarts Theater) in Disney Music Center
on September 23, 2015
As the audience moves to their seats
in the production of Philippe Quesne’s play La
Mélancolie des dragons, we observe a stage apparently covered with snow, a
large white mat of felt on the floor and a series of seemingly dead (or wintry)
trees covered with the substance. In the middle of the field sits an automobile
attached to which is a small trailer of the kind that reminds one of the
traveling performers in the opera Pagliacci,
but here arriving in a dead world instead of a vitally excited small colorful
Italian city.
From time to time, we get a notion that there are people in the car,
and, as the lights go down, we see there are indeed four individuals in the
auto, all with very long tresses, munching on chips and swigging down cans of
beer, while the car radio blasts out various heavy-metal, and from
time-to-time, even classical pieces, the four nodding their heads in their
rhythms.
We soon discover, in fact, that we have been mistaken about their
genders, perhaps hinting what Quesne’s play soon reveals: people are not always
who or what they appear to be. At that very moment, a middle-aged Asian woman
(Isabelle Angotti) bicycles into the glen, the four gradually piling out of the
car a bit like circus clowns, revealing that they are all men.
Were these 7 heavy-metal dudes actually on their way to some gig, the
news might have resulted in a great deal of grumbling and even teeth-gnashing,
but these are apparently very gentle men, who, speaking English with slightly
French accents, seem to be as placid and slow-minded as tortoises.
When the Asian woman queries them about their trailer, they respond that
it is, in fact, a kind of amusement park, and gently invite her to become the onstage audience of their show. Lifting
up the felt snowpad, as if it were the most natural thing in the world, they
plug in a cord which lights up the trailer to reveal it is fronted by glass,
and holds within a selection of wigs all held on rings, as if suggesting a
group of like-minded hirsute men. One explains that they also have a video
projector to project words on the side of the trailer, helping to explain the
objects and their actions.
A bit later, one of their kind displays a small snow-making machine,
suggesting that the winter wonderland around them, in fact, has been of their
creation. Presenting her with a pair of skies, the men take her through a ski
run by lifting up and rolling the felt padding so that she might pretend to ski
down slopes.
Their small trailer also contains a fan, which they soon put to use by
blowing up a large white plastic bag, carrying it ritualistically through the
landscape. With lighting and projections, they change the colors of the
landscape and suggest possible names for their cabinet of curiosities-amusement
park.
Throughout all of this, the car repair
person seems genuinely amazed and absolutely delighted to have been able to
immerse herself in their surprising world. Bringing out champagne and glasses,
these 8 individuals—who may be, after all, not as simple as they
appear—celebrate their success, quickly promising one more grand amusement:
shortly after they, one by one, blow up four even larger black plastic bags,
uprighting them to look a bit like a black forest of, very possibly, the
melancholy dragons of the play’s title, which ends both their entertainment and
the “drama” we have been observing—restating what he have recognized all along,
that the work’s actions and significance are one in the same.
If all of this is meant to sound like a
radical intellectual redefinition of theater, at least as French critic Sara
Sugiharabio would have it, in fact, it is rather too simplistic. While La Mélancolie des dragons presents us
with the wondrous childlike roots—the innocent amusements—which are at the
heart of all theater, as a play it is not that profound. If this is how theater
begins—and it is good to be reminded of that—Quesne’s play eschews all the
deeper and richer possibilities of dramatic literature, arguing rather that art
is most transformative at its simplest.
The wonder of theater, as playwright Mac Wellman has suggested in his
early anthology of plays, Theater of
Wonders* is that the greatest of its marvels are often arrived at through
the most linguistically challenging and thematically complex of issues, some of
which are inexplicable. While elemental theater surely reveals the genre’s
charms, it may be at its best as a more highly artificed combine.
La Mélancolie des dragons,
however, is significant enough that I look forward to seeing other works by
Phillippe Quesne and his Theatre of Vivarium Studio, and am joyful that Redcat
has brought his work to Los Angeles.
Los Angeles, September 24, 2015
Reprinted from AmericanTheater, Opera, and Performance (September 2015).
*Mac Wellman Theatre of Wonders: Six Contemporary American Plays (Los Angeles:
Sun & Moon Press, 1985),