Search the List

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Missy Mazzoli (music), Royce Vavrek (libretto) | Lincoln at the Bardo / 2026 [Metropolitan Opera-HD live production]

at the core

by Douglas Messerli


Missy Mazzoli (music), Royce Vavrek (libretto) | Lincoln at the Bardo / 2026 [Metropolitan Opera-HD live production]

 

With a libretto by Royce Vavrek (based on the fiction of the same name by George Saunders), a score by Missy Mizzoli, and directed on stage by Lileana Blain-Cruz, Lincoln at the Bardo opened with great acclaim on October 19, 2026. Audiences appeared to adore the production, and critics such George Grella, writing in New York Classical Review delighted in the Met’s first commissioned opera from a female composer:

 

“The result is a fertile combination of creative minds and material. Saunders’ novel is populated with multiple characters speaking and thinking in multiple voices— almost begging for a set of singers—and Mazzoli is one of the most talented, if not always consistent, living opera composers. Throw in the fantastical nature of the story, and there’s a good possibility for some magic to happen.

     And there was magic on the stage Monday night, including an enviable cast that includes baritone Peter Mattei as Lincoln, mezzo-soprano Stephanie Blythe, countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo, bass-baritone Ryan McKinny, and soprano Janai Brugger. There were prosaic moments as well, some from the story itself, and some from the adaptation by Mazzoli and librettist Royce Vavrek.”

 

     Writing in The New Yorker Nathan Heller in his essay “A Song of Grief and Union in Lincoln in the Bardo” suggests that Mazzoli and Vavrek delivered a “charismatic, openhearted work”..that deliver in “the form of a comedy with a melancholy guise.” Praising Mizzoli’s music, in particular, he writes:

 

“In Lincoln in the Bardo she has produced a rich twenty-first-century score with musical shadows of both the Civil War era and the Halloween graveyard, opening with a spooky stacked minor tone cluster (made spookier by knitting needles rattling the percussion) and extending to gorgeous snatches of chocolatey writing in the low brass, befitting a bereaved President. The orchestra, under the direction of Yannick Nézet-Séguin, comes at the music with terrific confidence, delivering the wort of fully conceived performance that rarely awaits brand-new work…. The intelligence of her dramatic writing haunts the score. She make much of big glissandos, in which the men and women of the chorus slide together through a scale, like a winding siren. Heading upward, these slides impart moments of ecstatic, unworldly levitation. Send downward, they plummet us into the earth.”

 

     Commenting on the cast, critic David Salazar, writing in OperaWire comments on strong performances from the young boy, Everett Sobers, who plays Lincoln’s recently dead son Willie to Christine Goerke’s “pants” performance as the Reverend. He describes the latter performance as “her most impressive performance at the Met to date, the voice clear, elegant, and potent in the space. There was delicacy mixed with a more sardonic edge throughout the Act two monologue and tenderness in the interactions with Willie. But that aside, and perhaps most impressive was that I didn’t recognize Goerke onstage. The costume design by Montana Levi Blanco and makeup team did tremendous heavy lifting here, but Goerke’s physicality must also be spotlighted and commended. She was not just playing a character but viscerally inhabiting it.”

    Other performances he praises include Ryan McKinny and Jonah Hoskins, who “proved a tremendous duo, playing off each other well, their voices melding well with one another. Ditto for Stephanie Blythe and Craig Colclough as the bickering couple whose more accented singing added a unique texture to the soundscape.”

    “Joshua Blue had a revelatory performance as Thomas Havens, not only with the precision of his aria’s faster sections, but also gentle legato he displayed in its second half. During all of his appearances, he let his honeyed tenor shine with ease and he brought a tranquility and longing to the musical mosaic. In the final scene of the opera, during which the three Black characters commune with Lincoln and declare their hope for a better future, his voice coalesced well with Mattei’s.”

     He closes this section of his essay: “I didn’t forget about Peter Mattei as Lincoln. It’s surprising that for a story in which he is the titular character, how peripheral he seems to the proceedings. He effectively has a handful of scenes and doesn’t sing much in some of them, but his presence looms large, literally and figuratively. We await his arrival. Willie pines for his return. Characters scheme around that return. And eventually, he comes to the realization that he has to accept his son’s death. His arc mirrors Willie’s in this way (again, brilliant story structure). I can’t imagine anyone else besides Mattei in this role. Not only is the baritone’s physical nature perfect for the famously tall Commander-in-Chief, but his calm and collected demeanor, coupled with a flawless voice, is nothing short of Presidential. His singing, while composed, was full of stinging melancholy. As he wept for his song and repeated his ‘I promise,’ you could sense the composure breaking, the pain giving way. But the most powerful moments came at the close – as he comes to terms with how broken everyone is, Mattei lets his Lincoln weep and the falsetto evocations of ‘Willie is dead,’ were the most affecting moment of the entire night. Credit Mazzoli for taking the risk to write that vocal line and Mattei for pulling them off with such care and vulnerability.”

 

   And these are just a sampling of the positive reviews.

  I was finally able to see the free HD-production on YouTube on its next to last day, offered instead of in the usual theater setting, since it was not originally scheduled as a regular filmed production, the Metropolitan quickly realizing with the great success of their opening that they had perhaps made a mistake in not putting it on their regular schedule, although one might suppose they originally felt that its subject matter and plot were far too strange for that venue. But they quickly corrected their miscalculation, and used the HD-performance, instead, as a fund-raising effort, providing those of us unable to see the New York production an opportunity to experience this operatic masterwork.

    And yes, I too was enthralled and almost mesmerized by the beauty of the music, singing, puppetry by James Ortiz, the sets by Adam Rigg, and the special effects by Jeremy Chernick, as well as the always wonderful Met chorus.

     The plot is another thing. And when I say that, I am not inferring that it too wasn’t totally engaging and involving, wondrous most of the time, and absolutely astounding at others. But one has too admit that Lincoln at the Bardo has one of the weirdest stories of all opera history. Moreover, the story in this case is told in a manner quite unusual to most operas, embedded as they generally are in deep historic events or in the case more modern operas, characters that are early on delineated in the first act by the text.

     Rather, in this work almost all is linear, one tale told after the other in succession, so that it is not until the end that we can truly tie the pieces laid out before us together. It is not that history as no role in this opera. Lincoln and the Civil War, obviously, stand substantially as a backdrop against which the events of the work occur. But given the strange and other-worldly placement of the numerous figures we meet, except for at the end of the second act, they seem almost out of touch with that grounding. And, in fact, despite the fact that Lincoln’s love, loss, and grieving for son are at the heart of the work, they seem almost incidental in their linear thrust to the war which is never discussed in any detail, but relies on our own knowledge of what that war meant.   


   The opera begins, instead, in Washington, D.C.’s Oak Hill Cemetery in 1892 with the almost comic pairing of a man named Vollman (Ryan McKinny) and his new-found friend Bevins (Jonah Hoskins). Both died in incidents relating to love. Vollman, outlandishly and seemingly inappropriately is provided with gigantic penis, which keeps erecting or deflating depending on his state of mind. He has married a beautiful young woman, but on their wedding night as he enters her room to have sex, he suddenly finds himself unable to deflower the beautiful virgin and instead asks her to simply become his friend. They live happily that way for some time until she herself begins to desire sex, and finally on the very day that he is about to do something about it, he is struck down by a beam and killed outright.

     Perhaps the aperture is something acquired as an award only after his meaninglessly chaste life. But the joke seems somewhat course and pointless given his story and confuses us at the very beginning of the opera about the tone of the rest of the piece. As anyone who knows my writing will tell you, I am anything but prudish or moralistic. But here I just feel that the opera began in a direction that, fortunately, it never pursued.


   Bevins, a gay boy, is desperately in love with his young friend. Both have sex, but attempt to control their appetites, quite unsuccessfully as he tells it, describing the numerous places where they daily meet up for pleasure. Eventually, when his friend rejects his full love, however, he cuts his wrists with a razor.

     Suddenly seeing Willie standing on the top of his burial tomb, they are both shocked. Both live in what they perceive as the Bardo, a place were the sick go to get well, perceiving their own graves simply as recuperating beds. Everyone in the Bardo has a story to tell and hopes to get well enough to return back to normal life. But what they do immediately perceive is that the Bardo, with its many dangers of tendrils, horrific tales, and hauntings is not the place for a young boy.

     Bevins and Vollman, who become central to the plot, fetch the Reverend (Goerke), who we discover in the second act is the only one in the Bardo—the traditional Tibetan limbo between life and the afterlife—who knows that they are all actually dead. He has experienced the judgment and been found not worthy, despite his life of piety and supposedly good deeds; instead of facing his fate in this strangely Christian interpretation of judgment and damnation, he turns and runs, ending up, like all the others in a world of horror.

   Yet, he does do good deeds here, if nothing else by helping give advice and succor to those who believe they will soon recover and return to life.

     Together, the three of them try to convince the boy that he should not tarry in the Bardo, but should accept his fate and leave them. In an effort to show him one of the worst instances of what might happen, they determine to take him on a visit to Miss Elise Traynor. But on the way they first run into the Barons (Stephanie Blythe and Craig Colclough) a couple who have spent their lives as drunkards, not even keeping their eyes on their own children. When they finally go on search of a missing son, lost somewhere in the crowds, they are run over by a carriage, both of them dying in the process.

      This raucous couple, partly in recompense for their guilt for their children having suddenly found themselves with either father or mother, despise children, further scarring little Willie. But the young boy is determined to wait it out for his father to come for him.


    Even worse than the Hodges is Miss Elise Traynor, performed in mad drag by Anthony Roth Costanzo. Countertenor Costanzo is one of my very favorite opera performers, a true pioneer who performed a scene in the nude in Philip Glass’ opera Akhnaten. He he is here willing to go way off the score in his howling rendition of a 14-year-old girl, now entangled in the cemetery tendrils and by the memories of hands, pigs, and other beings and objects which appear from time-to-time from under her vast dress. Some critics did not approve of his performance, Salazar, for example, describing it as a voice “that filled the hall even though there was an unevenness to his approach which oscillated between straight tone to notably wide vibrato on some phrases.” But he is said to have performed the highest note in this performance ever heard on the Met stage, and I can only applaud his approach as appropriate for a young woman furious for dying of a fever before she has had any of the opportunities to experience marriage or motherhood.   


    While the others, reminding one a bit of Dorothy of The Wizard of Oz, just want to go home, in a nearby tree sits Mrs. Francis Hodge (Janai Brugger) on a tree limb, accompanied by the African American slave woman Litzie (Viviana Goodwin) who sits permanently quiet due to the trauma she has suffered from rape, the former of which wants only revenge on all men for having had her children stolen from her.

    Suddenly a choir of angels appears encouraging all to accept the “MatterLightBloom” which will send them to their proper destinations. Bevins and Vollman suggest to Willie that the best thing he can do is simply duck as if he were in a World War I trench during a blitz, and wait it out. On this trip Willie is almost convinced to join the angels, but sees his father returning to his mausoleum and runs to greet him.

      Lincoln (Mattei), disconsolate with the death of his beloved son, holds what he believes is his child in his arms. Frustrated that to the boy it looks as if he were speaking and holding only a worm, he slips through his father’s empty arms and attempts to console him.

    The others notice “the profound intimacy” between the two, having nearly forgotten what it was like to hold and touch others, and they are sincerely moved by the situation. They also recognize who Willie’s father is, Lincoln, the president himself. Willie is able to perceive his father’s inner thoughts where he hears his father insist he will return.

     Willie remains in the Bardo, accordingly, in the beginning of the 2nd, shorter act, but by now the tendrils have captured him. Lincoln returns and in tears lifts the body of his son from his grave,  as the men struggle to free the boy from the fast growing vines. Before they can do so, however, Lincoln has again wandered off.

     Spotting Lincoln still walking alone in the cemetery, Bevins and Vollman determine to see if they too might weave their way into his consciousness to bring him back to the mausoleum to convince Willie that he should accept the “MatterLightBloom.”

      While they are gone, the Reverend reveals his long story of how he came upon his destination with the afterlife along with a ginger chap and a doodling Pennsylvanian. He now realizes that only if he himself accepts the “MatterLightBloom” will the boy be able to follow his example, and in a burst of pyrotechnics he is gone.


       The duo do wind their way into the president’s consciousness and succeed in bringing him back to the boy, who freed from the tendrils sits to talk with his father on a nearby bench.  

   He soon after crawls into his lap, finally able to hear his father’s full thoughts. As Lincoln recalls his son’s illness and passing, the boy comes to comprehend that he is already dead, unable to return home. And as his father finally realizes that he can no longer hold on to someone or something that is gone, Willie feels totally freed, delighted to know that he is already dead and free to join the choirs of angels. He celebrates this with the news the entire bardo community, who in the process finally come recognize that they too must be dead and can be freed through the light offered them.


    As Bevins and Vollman watch Willie transcend through the glorious fireworks, they convince Miss Traynor to join them also in the “MatterLightBlooming,” the entire stage now coming to life as flashes of light.

     Earlier, a former slave, Thomas Havens (Joshua Blue) has attempted to convince Mrs. Hodge and Litzie to come down from the tree as he recounts his few hours of free pleasure allowed on Wednesdays and Sundays—when it wasn’t necessary to call him back to work.


    He now feels Lincoln’s presence as he passes and, like Willie, is able to share with the President the necessity of continuing the painful Civil War to help free men like him so that they can become engaged in the society. Litzie herself suddenly comes to life, singing a glorious aria to the possibilities for those like herself.

     Indeed, Havens appears to have now become one with the President, as he goes off with him on his black stallion, the opera coming to an end, as the Bardo returns, at least temporarily, to simply being a memorial to the dead, instead a world of sorrow and desire to return to mankind.

     The strange work, just by its linear push, finally pushes us into new territory. One could only wish that librettist Royce Vavrek were poet enough to help elevate the story with his language. But unfortunately, like so many contemporary librettists, he is stuck in the vernacular and cannot seem, accept for moments at a time, to escape the limitations of everyday speech, often simply repeating words, almost like a stutterer, that only reiterates the problems of the work’s linearity, rather than helping it interweave the poetry of the world they have left behind with their own lives, which might have created a deeper sense of history.

      The repetitions might be appropriate for the 14-year-old Miss Elise Traynor or even the fixated Mrs. Hodge. But certainly Lincoln, the Reverend, and even Vollman and Bevins should have been able to speak, at least for a few moments each, in a more magical language that didn’t simply delineate plot. Only Havens and perhaps Litzie seem, in the end, to find something of depth about which they can sing.

      My complaints do not mean that the work isn’t a true success; all operas have their faults, the very impossibility of so many different elements coming fully together in such a form being obvious. This opera is already close—in its odd pairing of story with the themes of loss, despair, and the desire for the dead to remain with the living that lie at the core of all of us—to being a true classic.

 

Note: All but the two first photographs above were provided the Metropolitan Opera Company for reviewers, photographed by Karen Almond.

 

Los Angeles, November 19, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (November 2026).  

Kyle Motsinger (music and lyrics), Tyler Willam Milliron (director) | Parallel Universe / 2019 [music video]

 leaving the hunk behind

by Douglas Messerli

 

Kyle Motsinger (music and lyrics), Tyler Willam Milliron (director) Parallel Universe / 2019 [4.30 minutes] [music video]

 

In this song by genre-breaking singer Kyle Motsinger, he wonders what might have happened if he had settled down with his gay lover in the small town in which he grew up, realizing that he would simply not have known the joys of his escape to New York City. He realizes that even for the hot lover he has left behind in the country, he couldn’t have survived. As he puts it in the song:


I couldn’t stay here

Even for a guy

In the middle of nowhere

I think my dreams would die

 

Opportunities I couldn’t find here

In a town not ruled by courage but by fear 

 

In another universe

You moved with me

We rented an apartment

In the heart of NYC

 

We’d explore the city

Side-by-side

End our days making love

Completely satisfied

 

    Now, back visiting his home town he realizes the had he remained there he would have indeed lived in a parallel universe.

 

Chose the road less taken.

I’m glad I did!

That poem by Robert Frost

I read it as a kid

Followed it to New York

One September day

Leaving my hometown

Eight hundred Miles away


Being back I wonder

What my life would be

If I lived here in the country

What would become of me?

 

In a parallel universe I stayed                       

After college I moved back to town

No other plans were made

 

Got a job

Got a dog right by my side

Settling for a slower life

Completely satisfied!

 

Wouldn’t know any better

Any worse

In that parallel universe

 

…..

 

In a parallel universe I stayed

We bought a house together

Front porch, sipping lemonade

 

Deep in love

You here by my side

Two country boys, the simple life

Completely satisfied

 

Couldn’t ask for someone better

To converse

In our parallel universe


    And he finally realizes that if he hadn’t chased his dreams, left the hunky hometown boy beyond, he would have not survived.

 

If I hadn’t chased my dreams, put myself first

I’d be in that parallel universe

I’d be in that parallel universe

 

    This film clearly reveals how sometimes a man has to leave his provincial lover behind or convince him to more on into the larger world.

 

Los Angeles, August 2, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (August 2026).

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Andy Warhol | Paul Swan / 1965 [film on dance]

 paul swan and the aesthetic

by Douglas Messerli

 

Andy Warhol (director) Paul Swan / 1965

 

As I observed in my July 2022 essay on Charles W. Allen and Francis Trevelyan Miller’s 1916 film, Diana, the Huntress, in which dancer Paul Swan performed as Pan, Swan was perceived as a major dancer throughout his early years. That work was choreographed by modern dance pioneer Ruth St. Denis, herself highly influenced the aesthetic principles laid out by François Delsarte, his disciples and his Society of Gymnastics and Voice Culture.


     Delsarte, who had inexplicably lost his voice, began a search to comprehend the relationship between personal emotions and physical gestures, over time developing a codified system connecting mental attitudes, physical postures, and gestures. He believed that one’s emotional state could in fact be communicated through one’s physical appearance and performance.

     For example, the extension of the body would be in relationship with the feeling of self-realization; the feeling of annihilation would translate into a bending of the body. Practicing those positions would reinforce the feelings they traduce and all emotions would have their own bodily translation. The gesture reinforced the emotions and the emotions were reinforced by the gestures. Arguably, this was an early Western version of ideas that had long been in action in Eastern thought, that such would also be able to help the dancer or gesturer to open himself up to  those emotions. And accordingly the gesture came to take precedence to the verbal language used to describe the gesture. As he wrote:

 

“What we say is not what persuades but how we say it. The speech is inferior to the gesture because this last one corresponds to the phenomenon of the spirit. The gesture is the agent of heart, the persuasive agent. Sometimes 100 pages cannot say what one sole gesture can express, because in that simple movement our whole being comes to the surface”

 

His codification of the system was also organized under the omnipresence of what some historians call his “understanding of the Christian concept of the trinity,” influenced presumably by this ideological system and the thought of Saint Augustine, the medieval scholasticism and the Neo-Platonism.

     His theory is full of classifications that are always divided into three categories. Called applied aesthetics, it is divided in three parts: the statics, the dynamics and the semiotics.

     The body similarly is divided in three zones: the physical, the emotional and the mental, which correspond to the inferior members, trunk and arms, and neck and head respectively.

     Delsarte argued, moreover, that there are three languages: the affective, transmitted through voice, the elliptic, expressed through gestures and the philosophical, traduced by the articulated word.

      Movement is of three orders: opposition, parallelism and succession, according to the intervention of the physical, emotional or mental part.

       Movement, moreover, is divided into three categories: eccentric, concentric, and normal. And there are three laws for movement (The laws of harmonic movement):

 

1. Law of the harmonic posture: there’s a need to obtain a balanced and natural attitude like the position of perfect rest in Greek statues.

2. Law of opposed movement: every movement of one or several parts of the body demands, for balance principles, an opposed movement of the rest of the segments.

3. Law of the harmonic muscular function or of the succession of contractions: the force of a muscular function must be in direct relationship with the size of the muscles. Therefore muscles should start from the big muscles that surround the pelvis.

 

    Delsarte had two major pupils who spread his theories, Steele MacKaye and Genevieve Stebbins, and it is these two spread the word to modern figures such as Ted Shawn, Isadora Duncan. Ruth St. Denis, and Rudolph Laban.

     By this time, however, Delsarte (1811 – 1871) had been almost forgotten in France, and as his ideas became popular in the US, his teachings quickly became so distorted and mechanized that the entire system soon lost its reputation and grew out of favor.

     Indeed by the time Paul Swan began dancing under its influence it had already begun to grow out of favor.

 

     As I wrote on his 1916 film dancing: “As Pan, Swan presents another, far more innovative dance pattern, although also highly influenced by the Delsarte’s Aesthetic. By this time, however, Swan had already done some of his entirely nude dances which intrigued and scandalized dance admirers and which would later find a ready enthusiast in Isadora Duncan, with whom Swan may have had an affair.

     Although he does not appear nude here, the young Swan, billed as ‘the most beautiful man in the world,’ represents a Pan who is sufficiently undressed to make his movements appear scandalous to some viewers of the 1916 short.”


      Indeed, the eroticism of Swan's nude and near-nude performances was shocking and innovative for the time. A journalist described the reaction of Paris audiences to shows that Swan starred in: "even this gay city has been shocked really and truly by the prevailing cult of nakedness, whose expositions grow more and more daring." Swan described himself in 1915 as "the only man in the world who has the courage to take off his clothes and dance." Surely given his nude dances he might have been arrested and imprisoned, even more so because of his known homosexuality. But his apparent heterosexual marriage to the open-minded Helen Gavit certainly accounted for something. As his biographer Richard Londraville wrote, "He was able to walk through the world much more freely than most homosexuals would at the time. He was very lucky to have a wife that he could fall back on."

     In his speech after the performances that Andy Warhol recorded on tape in 1965, he bragged still that he had never once been jailed.

      In the early 1930s Swan moved permanently to Paris, both painting and dancing. Most of the former except his portraits of Duncan have been lost because of the Nazi occupation. And his dances from that period are now forgotten. In the late 1930s he returned to the US, took up residence in the few Carnegie Hall apartments and from 1939 to 1969 danced and declaimed in Sunday night recitals almost without a break. Among the many who attended his recitals were Marcel Duchamp, Alexander Calder, and others. Presumably Warhol had attended before determining to film him.

     Although the Aesthetic by 1965, when Swann was 88, had long been abandoned by modern and contemporary dancers, and Swann himself had studied other methods, even becoming a private pupil early on with Diaghilev’s Ballet Russes star Mikhail Mordkin, he continued to perform the Aesthetic. And it was that outlandish devotion to a tradition which surely he knew was totally out of style and meaningless that apparently led Warhol to describe him as the very definition of the “camp aesthetic.”


    For anyone without knowledge of who this man was or without comprehending his absurd devotion to a method long lost, Warhol’s film of this elderly man who can hardly any longer move his limbs and who spends much of his time changing into skimpy, outdated costumes which he himself had made, some of the accessories, as he admits, purchased in the dime stores, must seem simply pathetic.

      Swan does not seem at all embarrassed about a no longer attractive body, dressing and undressing almost in the nude in front of the camera. Moreover, he not at all embarrassed for quoting, in the first piece, long passages from the outdated Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam, gesticulating in the broad hand waves of the Aesthetic.

      In his elegy for World War I soldiers, he jousts with a wooden sword and kills dozens in his dance “Two Hero’s Slain” before laying down the sword in surrender.

     In his “Three Oriental Numbers”—of which I could discern only two—he don’s his skimpiest of costumes to play out the stereotypes of Asian dance and culture.


     Unable to find his black slippers in order to correctly perform his “French Peasant Dance,” he spends the end of the first reel and much of the beginning of the second behind the stage curtain swearing at the situation as Warhol’s cameraman or others keep calling for him to come out and perform even with the wrong shoes. Finally, his pianist joins in the search and Swann finally reappears.

      Whereas the camera of the first reel was static, allowing us to observe the dance properly in full perspective, the second reel represents a moving camera, which truly does turn Swann’s performance into something very close to Jack Smith’s Normal Love and Ron Rice’s Chumlum of the previous year.

      As he attempts to dress for one more dance, the photographers realize they are quickly running out of film and request that he appear, he arguing that they are probably going to cut most of it anyway, but finally he does reappear to declaim some of his own poems, again embarrassingly outdated works with rhyming couplets and archaic language. The following poem is typical [line breaks mine]

 

           I sometimes think that love is only pain.

           And when your sad eyes smile I think it’s only ecstasy.

           When you’re from my side, love seems only longing

           and unrest. And when I kiss your lips contentment sweet

           is all I know. So, what is love? It won’t be every mood

           and every mood somehow reflects it less and less of you.

     

    His final speech, beginning with his statement of never having been in jail, ends abruptly as the camera runs out of film.


    Rather than perceiving him as pathetic I endured the entire 66 minutes with fascination—yes, also with frustration—and admiration that someone could continue to be so totally devoted to something he surely recognized as laughable and outré. His stubborn performance was without hesitation or analysis, almost as if were keeping the tradition of the art in which he was educated alive despite the fact that he could no longer move gracefully or, at moments, even step into his shorts he wore that represented the characters he attempted to emulate.

     As Susan Sontag noted, the essence of camp is “its love of the unnatural: of artifice and exaggeration,” that sexually it goes against the grain, cherishing either the androgynous or the extreme sexuality of figures such as Jayne Mansfield and Victor Mature; its source is from passion and naiveté not from a winking, mocking knowledge of its idols. Just as Jean Genet argued for a sense of elegance, so Oscar Wilde argued for style over sincerity. I would add that camp emulates mannerism as opposed to pure originality. And it emanates always from the sincere even while its queerness or oddity of viewpoint is recognized.

     Seeing these performances of Paul Swan, one can only agree that Swan is enacting the sacredness of a camp experience. And it is clear why Warhol included him in his film of the same year, Camp.

 

Los Angeles, October 9, 2022

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (October 2022).

Missy Mazzoli (music), Royce Vavrek (libretto) | Lincoln at the Bardo / 2026 [Metropolitan Opera-HD live production]

at the core by Douglas Messerli Missy Mazzoli (music), Royce Vavrek (libretto) | Lincoln at the Bardo / 2026 [Metropolitan Opera-HD live pr...